It is truly bittersweet to announce that Bluestone Tavern will be serving its last meal on July 21, 2019. While we are sad that we will no longer be operating the business, we are excited to be leasing the property to exemplary restauranteurs. The new operators are the proprietors of an extensive portfolio of a la carte locations, including Besito in West Islip, Roslyn and Huntington, NY and Chestnut Hill, Massachusetts as well as The Shed, also located in Huntington, NY. We are confident that they will deliver a great product and undoubtedly will be an asset to the Sayville community.

Additionally, the divestment of Bluestone Tavern will enable us to focus on our core business of exquisite, catered events. We look forward to continuing to serve our guests at all of our established New York locations, including Land’s End Waterfront Catering, Flowerfield Celebrations, Audrey’s Bakery, Tribeca Rooftop and Tribeca 360, as well as at our locations in North Myrtle Beach, South Carolina. In addition, we are very excited to continue to expand our events business to 180 Maiden Lane in New York City as well as in Pompano Beach, Florida.

We have owned and operated the business at 21 Main Street in West Sayville, New York since 2003, first as 21 Main Prime Steakhouse and since 2014, as Bluestone Tavern. It has been our sincere honor and pleasure to serve this community, where we have and will continue to have so many ties. We are very grateful to all of our customers over the years as well as our fine employees who made serving you possible.

Thank you again for your patronage.

Lovin’ Oven Catering

West Sayville’s Best
Gathering Place


n. a pub that specializes in serving high-quality food.

mon. 4pm-10pm
tues-thur 11:30am–10pm
fri-sat 11:30am–11pm
sun 11:30am–9pm
red dots

Featured as One of The Top 10 Gastropubs on Long Island, The Bluestone Tavern assumes the place of 21 Main Steakhouse, maintaining much of its culinary tradition and influences, but with an updated, pub friendly vision.

burger iconPUB MENU
*consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs, may increase your rish of food bourne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.
drink iconTHE BAR

$10 Cocktails

mango margarita

tequila / triple sec / mango puree / lemon & lime

blueberry mojito

muddled blueberries & mint / white rum / lemonade / splash of club soda

peach basil moscow mule

peach vodka / basil leaves / ginger beer

cucumber watermelon lemonade

tito's vodka / cucumber watermelon lemonade / cucumber & lemon

Reserve Wine List

malbec reserva kaiken / $36

Mendoza Argentina, 2015

sterling vintner’s collection chardonnay/ $28

California, 2013

mirassou pinot noir / $38

California, 2014

cavit pinot grigio / $18

Italy, 2011

chateau souverain cabernet / $34

California, 2014

movendo moscato / $34

Italy, 2012

  • The Blustone Tavern offers a wide variety beer from our 14 taps, as well as top shelf liquors from our full service bar.

  • beer on tap

    bluepoint seasonal
    sam adams seasonal
    montauk seasonal
    lagunitas ipa ca / 6.2% landshark lager fl / 4.7% blue moon belgian wheat co / 5.4% ship yard monkey fist me / 6.9% bass ale uk / 5.1% dog fish head 60 min ipa de / 6.0% guinness ireland / 4.2% blue point toasted lager ny / 5.3% stella artois belgium / 5.0%

  • assorted liquors

    bourbon whiskey
    american whiskey
    irish whiskey
    rye whiskey
    bottled beer
    wine by the glass


monday – thursday (draft room only) / 5pm – 7pm

$2 OFF Bottled and Draft Beer

$2 OFF House Wine by the Glass

tuesday – friday / 11:30am - 4pm

Burger & A Pint, STARTING AT $15

monday – friday / 5pm - 10pm

$2 OFF Reserved Bottled Wine

friday (draft room only) / 3pm – 7pm

$2 OFF Bottle and Draft Beer

$2 OFF House Wine by the Glass

$2 OFF Well Drinks

taco icon

taco tuesdays

join us for the perfect pair

$5 margarita / $2 tacos

Guest’s choice of fish, beef or chicken.

Chef’s choice of preparation updated weekly!

May Specials


Grilled Chicken / Cheddar & Jack / BBQ / Pickled Red Onion / Cilantro


Burger of the Month

Seasoned Ground Beef / Cheddar / Jalapenos / Pico De Gallo / Tortilla Chips


Grilled Cheese of the Month

Mozzarella & Gruyere / Sliced Sirloin / Mushrooms, Peppers, Onions / Brown Gravy


stay up-to-date

join our email list for the latest specials and events at The Bluestone Tavern


Host your next event with us; from birthday parties to wedding dinners,
let us make it one to remember! Private Event Rooms Available. / 631.567.0900 / Download Catering Menu

  • Banquet Room

    Max Sit Down 45 – 50 people
    Max Cocktail Party 50 people
    Max Buffet 35 people
    Min To Book 25 people
    Available 11am – 11pm
    Private Rest Room, Balcony & Bar

  • BST Patio

    Max Sit Down 40 people
    Cocktail Party & Buffet Only
    Min To Book 25 people
    Available Outdoors May thru Sept. 11am – 11pm
    Banquet Space is held as rain backup

  • Main Dining Room

    Max Sit Down 45 – 50 people
    Max Buffet 70 people
    Min To Book 40 people
    Available 11am – 3:30pm

Connect with Us

Photo: pub food
Photo: pub food
Photo: pub food
Photo: pub food
Photo: pub food
Photo: pub food
Photo: pub food
Photo: pub food
Photo: pub food
Photo: pub food
Photo: pub food
Photo: pub food